Snow
in Beijing and What it Means for Gold
U.S. Treasury Secretary John Snow visited Beijing recently to
raise the Renminbi (RMB) re-valuation issue with Chinas
senior leadership. While the media focus was on currency values
and unfair trade advantages, what is sometimes overlooked is
the potential implications it has for gold.
Firstly, lets us consider the background behind the pressure
for RMB revaluation, and why for the foreseeable future, both
U.S. and China's interest are interlinked. At the root of the
international unhappiness with Chinas currency level is
the countrys rapidly growing trade surplus created by its
rented economy. The term rented economy
applies since foreign investment controls much of Chinas
low cost production. China is becoming the workshop/factory
of the world and is holding down global inflation.
Chinas senior leadership might still call themselves Communists,
however, in reality the country is run the like a holding company
along strict reporting lines with one clear objective, namely
7 to 8 % annual growth. The currency peg between the RMB and the
U.S. dollar is facilitating this growth objective while at the
same time it results in lower interest rates in the United States.
This is because, in order to keep the RMB at the 8.3 % level,
China needs to buy up surplus dollars and re-invest them abroad,
foremost in U.S. Treasury bonds. The peg is mutually beneficial
to both Chinas growth target and Alan Greenspans need
to keep long-term interest rates and inflation low.
As of last month Chinas holdings of U.S. Treasury bonds
rose to a record $122.5 billion, less then Japans but far
more than any other country. Together Japan and China hold 41.9%
of the $1347.2 billion debt the U.S. government owes the world.
Even though hot money is not allowed in, an unprecedented amount
of foreign currency is flowing into China, to buy land, construction
material and to pay workers to build new factories. These factories
start producing, much of their production is exported and sold
for U.S. dollars, while the raw materials used and the workers
wages are priced in RMB. As more foreign exchange flows into the
current account, the Peoples Bank of China (PBC), buys up
these dollars because the government is committed to keeping the
exchange rate stable.
If it were to stop buying the dollars, the value of the RMB would
quickly appreciate. But the PBC has a problem. If it simply uses
new RMB creating a liability on its balance sheet against
the dollar assets the extra money in circulation within
China would soon cause inflation, as indeed happened in the mid
1990s. That would damage the economy and eventually hurt Chinas
export industries, since the prices of Chinese goods would rise.
So instead of causing inflation inside the country, China is exporting
deflation.
This in turn allowed the Fed to spark an economic revival by lowering
interest rates to 45 year lows without risking inflation.
One weak spot of the recovery, however is the stubbornly high
U.S. unemployment rate. And this is where Mr. Snow comes in. President
Bush has already seen 2.7 million factory jobs disappear on his
watch and he needs to be seen to be doing something about it in
order to be re-elected. Viewed from this perspective, Mr. Snows
visit to Beijing is more about U.S. domestic political issues
rather than seriously forcing China to un-peg the currency.
All of the above leads us to the question what full RMB convertibility
eventually means for gold prices.
China can press onward toward convertibility on the capital account,
which would allow Chinese people more freedom to move their savings
abroad, counterbalancing the inflow of U.S. dollars. In many ways
that is the best option and it is already being implemented, but
it would threaten the steady increase of savings put in low interest
accounts at the state banks. This is the one thing that keeps
Chinas financial system stable at the moment. Historically,
the less trust there is in the financial system the more demand
there is for gold.
In addition, strong capital inflows and rising Forex reserves
are already sharply boosting official demand for gold in China.
This is because if the PBC is to retain its proportion of gold
holdings at the current 2.4% of total reserves (European Central
Bank standard: 15%), it would need to increase its gold holdings
by an estimated 120 tons or 60% of gold consumption in China in
2002.
China already enjoys with 40% one of the highest savings rates
in the world. The closer we get to revaluation, the more USD dollar
savings will be converted into gold.
In order to pave the way, the PBC last year relinquished its monopoly
on imports and exports of gold, the Shanghai Gold Exchange was
established and many Chinese commercial banks are planning to
launch personal gold investment businesses.
The
way forward for Chinas central bank and savers in the coming
years is, surely, to diversify out of their huge dollar holdings
and move to back its currency by gold as it heads slowly but surely
towards convertibility on the capital account.
After the Beijing Olympics when the snow falls in the winter
of 2008, gold might truly glitter.
Michael
R. Preiss serves as Chief Investment Strategist at CFC Securities.