Emerging
Market Briefs
By
Scott B. MacDonald
Guatemala– Presidential
Elections: On November 9th, 2003 Guatemalans went to the
polls to elect a new president. Former Guatemala City Mayor
Oscar Berger received 47.6% of the vote, while center-left
candidate Alvaro Colom finished second with 26.4%. Retired
General Efrain Rios Montt came in third with 11.2%. To
win the election, however, a candidate must gain more than
50% of the vote. Consequently, the top two candidates face
each other in a run-off election December 28.
Korea
- S&P Warning: S&P announced that it
thinks it is more likely that the North Korean government
led by the colorful Kim Jong-il would collapse rather
than gradually reform itself. The ratings agency also
urged South Korea to build the financial reserves that
will be required once the Northern regimes collapse takes
place. S&P noted that the North Korean collapse was
only a matter of time and when it comes it will cause
a greater shock to the South's economy than the 1997-98
Asian financial crisis. Although the North has started
to reform its command economy over the past year by liberalizing
wages and prices, the regime is simply too rigid to emulate
the market openings adopted by other communist governments
in China and Vietnam. As the rating agency stated: "Although
some other Asian nations that used to have centrally
planned economies have successfully moved to a market-based
system, the North Korean leadership probably lacks the
flexibility and vision to undertake such a change." To
this we would add, there are elements within North Korea's
leadership that clearly have a vested interest in no
change, rather maintaining the status quo, which allows
them to make a lot of money from trading in narcotics
and weapons, including the transfer of nuclear technology.
The North is constantly short of food and fuel and it
is desperate to develop a more solid bilateral relationship
with the United States in order to exact more aid and
stave off becoming more dependent on China. In a sense,
the North's view is better to become a U.S. client state
with Washington far away than a client state of China
next door.
Jordan – Changing the Guard: King Abdullah
II changed his government in October by asking Ali Abu Ragheb to
step down as prime minister and Faisal al-Fayez to assume that post.
Ragheb was the prime minister since June 2000 and presided over an
opening of the country to greater foreign trade, including a free
trade agreement with the United States. During his period in office
Ragheb allowed U.S. troops to deploy prior to the start of hostilities
in the last Iraq war, something that did little to endear him to
the majority of Jordanians. Ragheb also had problems with the economy.
He came into office promoting reforms that aimed to reduce poverty,
unemployment and corruption. Unfortunately, the Jordanian economy
was hard hit by the effects of the regional security situation on
tourism, a major source of foreign exchange. Growth fell from 4.9%
in 2002 to a more modest 3%, which is slower than the country’s
population growth rate. Al-Fayez is the former court minister, has
a close working relationship to the King and is regarded as both
pro-reform and pro-U.S. His new cabinet is smaller, shrinking from
29 ministers to 20, and is supposed to be more focused on reform.
At the same time, al-Fayez should benefit from stronger economic
growth expected in 2004, with the IMF forecasting 5.5% real GDP expansion.
Oman – ratings
Affirmed: n November 5, 2003, Standard & Poor’s
affirmed Oman’s BBB rating, with a stable outlook.
Poland: In early November, Fitch has
changed the outlook for Poland's BBB+ sovereign rating
from stable to positive, reflecting improvements in
foreign exchange reserves. In addition, Poland's financial
position will be reinforced by its just announced sale
of 7.5-8.5% of TPSA (it now currently owns 14% of the
Polish telecom). The sale of TPSA shares is expected
to raise Euro 376 million, which will help finance
the fiscal deficit and make up for lower tax revenues
related to slow economic growth. We do not expect the
sale of state shares will have any adverse impact on
TPSA as the ratings were not dependent on state ownership.
This was confirmed in conversations with both rating
agencies. Indeed, it is felt that the government's
intention to move ahead with the share sale will reduce
volatility in the company's stock.
Russia– GDP
Up, But Politics Hangs Like a Dark Cloud: Russian
real GDP expanded 6.5% percent in the first nine months
of 2003, compared to 4% growth over the same time in
2002, Russian Prime Minister Mikhail Kasyanov announced
on Oct. 23. Kasyanov added that the GDP is expected to
grow 6 percent overall in 2003, largely fueled by higher
energy prices. Despite the strong nature of the economy,
the political situation turned problematic in early November
when the Putin government arrested Yukos oil Chief Executive
Officer Mikhail Khodorkovsky on charges of fraud and
tax evasion. Moody’s had only the month before
generously raised Russia sovereign ratings from Ba2 to
Baa3, a two-notch upgrade. Now, Standard & Poor’s,
which rates Russia BB, is thinking of a possible downgrade,
stating: “Although we do not expect it at this
point, if the Yukos affair leads to a significant outflow
of capital and ensuing deterioration in economic activity,
then we would consider an outlook change or downgrade.” The
fundamental problem is that Russia’s recent strong
spurt of growth has been based on higher oil prices and
a substantial inflow of foreign capital, largely attracted
to opportunities in the hydrocarbon sector. The issues
concerning Khodorkovsky are directly related to the fact
that he refused to back out of being involved in the
country’s political life, in particular, ahead
of the upcoming Duma elections. Other Russian oligarchs
have either opted out of Russia (taking some of their
money with them to London and continental Europe) or
have quietly joined ranks with Putin, who appears to
have the support of the old security crowd in Russia.
None of this is positive for Russia and it makes a mockery
of Moody’s two notch upgrade.
Thailand – On
Review for an Upgrade: In early October Moody’s
placed Thailand’s Baa3 ratings on review for a
possible upgrade. If the upgrade occurs, which is widely
expected, Thailand will be climbing back up the ratings
ladder from which it fell in the aftermath of the Asian
financial crisis in 1997-98. Backing up the upgrade tide,
the government raised its estimate of how fast the economy
will grow over the next five years to 6% annually, up
from 5%. In addition, the nation’s budget is close
to being balanced for the time since 1997 and investors
have made the stock-market in Bangkok the best performer
in Asia. It is no surprise that Thai stocks are at six-year
highs.
Vietnam – A
Warning from Fitch: On November 6, Fitch sent
a warning to Hanoi about the country’s sovereign
rating. Although it is maintaining the BB- rating, it
changed the outlook from positive to stable and, if present
trends continue, we would not be surprises to see the
outlook go negative in the months ahead. The rating agency
changed its outlook on concerns about the widening trade
and current account deficits, excessive domestic credit
growth and a dispute with the International Monetary
Fund. Vietnam has enjoyed fast economic growth over the
last couple of years: 5.8% real GDP expansion in 2002,
with 6% expected in 2003. Rapid growth, however, has
fueled demand for imports, both as consumer goods and
industrial inputs. The trade deficit in 2003 could be
a record $4.5 billion, putting pressure on the current
account balance, which could top 7% of GDP, well above
IMF projections of 3.6% of GDP.
At the same time, credit at Vietnamese banks has increased by an annual rate
of 30% for the first half of the year. Even for a more developed banking system
this would place the banking system under pressure. In Vietnam, the banking
system still has considerable bad debt on the books, especially at the state-owned
banks that are still the dominant players. Public nervousness with the banks
is already evident as there was a ruin on a private-owned bank, largely due
to rumors. The message from Fitch is that while strong economic growth is great,
it must be balanced with ongoing structural reforms and proper regulation and
supervision in the financial sector. Without a balanced approach, Vietnam could
be heading into trouble.